iRubric: Module 1 Final Memo rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...
Module 1 Final Memo Rubric Code: X2X8265 Ready to use Public Rubric Subject: Engineering Type: Project Grade Levels: (none)

Formatting Descriptions
	Maximum Points 5 pts	Minor Errors 4 pts	Major Errors 3 pts	Missing 0 pts	n/a (N/A)
Organization, proofreading and clarity	Maximum Points Document flows and is well organized.	Minor Errors Majority of the document flows but some areas where flow and organization could be improved.	Major Errors Parts of the document flows but many areas where flow and organization could be improved.	Missing	n/a
Font size, margins, double spaced	Maximum Points Document has correct font size, margins and spacing.	Minor Errors Document has limited repeated error in font size, margins, spacing (i.e., the error is not isolate to only one location, but is not persistent throughout the document).	Major Errors Document has several repeated error in font size, margins, spacing (i.e., the error is not isolate to only one location, but is not persistent throughout the document).	Missing Document has persistent errors in font size, margins, or spacing, etc.	n/a
Figure & table formatting	Maximum Points Follows all rules for figure and table formatting.	Minor Errors Follows most of the rues for figure and table formatting.	Major Errors Follows some of the rues for figure and table formatting.	Missing	n/a
Memo formatting & Page length	Maximum Points Both are Maximum	Minor Errors Memo Formatting - YES Page Limit - Slightly Over	Major Errors Memo Formatting - NO Page Limit - YES -- OR -- Memo Formatting - YES Page Limit - Significantly Over	Missing	n/a
Needs Assessment and Problem Formulation
	Maximum Points 5 pts	Between Maximum & Minimum 4 pts	Minimum Requirements 3 pts	Missing 0 pts	n/a (N/A)
Brief Overview	Maximum Points Provides a complete but brief overview of the project (i.e., the customer and the need).	Between Maximum & Minimum	Minimum Requirements Has some introduction, but fails to introduce the customer or the general need (i.e., introduction is incomplete).	Missing	n/a
Needs Assessment and Problem Formulation
	5 Requirements 10 pts	4 Requirements 8 pts	3 Requirments 6 pts	2 Requirements 4 pts	1 Requirements 2 pts
Requirements	5 Requirements Has: 3 Explicit 2 Implicit	4 Requirements Has 4 of the following 5: 3 Explicit 2 Implicit	3 Requirments Has 3 of the following 5: 3 Explicit 2 Implicit	2 Requirements Has 2 of the following 5: 3 Explicit 2 Implicit	1 Requirements Has 1 of the following 5: 3 Explicit 2 Implicit
Analysis and Implementation: First cycle
	Maximum Points 5 pts	Satisfactory Response 4 pts	Non satisfactory Requirements 3 pts	Missing 0 pts	n/a (N/A)
Overall design with final form selected	Maximum Points Provides a complete overview of the final form selected for iteration one.	Satisfactory Response Discusses the final form of the first iteration, but discussion is not complete.	Non satisfactory Requirements	Missing	n/a
Design or component that was considered but not kept	Maximum Points Discusses a design that wasn't selected and clearly explains why that design was not selected using good reason/evidence.	Satisfactory Response Discuses a design that wasn't selected, but doesn't provide a full, complete reason/evidence for why the design wasn't selected.	Non satisfactory Requirements	Missing	n/a
Results of first test day	Maximum Points Provides a complete, comprehensive overview of the results from First Testing Day.	Satisfactory Response Provides a discussion of the results from First Testing Day and covers most of the results, but is not complete.	Non satisfactory Requirements	Missing	n/a
Appropriate figure of iteration 1 design	Maximum Points Includes a figure of Iteration 1 that is clear to see.	Satisfactory Response Includes a figure of Iteration 1, but the picture is not clear.	Non satisfactory Requirements	Missing	n/a
Analysis and Implementation: Second cycle
	Maximum Points 10 pts	Between Maximum and Satisfactory 9 pts	Satisfactory Response 8 pts	Non satisfactory Requirements 7 pts	Missing 0 pts
Table summarizing design changes	Maximum Points Table is complete and clearly outlines the reason for each change along with the outcome of each change.	Between Maximum and Satisfactory	Satisfactory Response Includes a table of the changes, reasons and outcomes, but the reasons and outcomes are not complete.	Non satisfactory Requirements	Missing
Discuss results of testing day	Maximum Points Provides a complete, comprehensive overview of the results from Second Testing Day.	Between Maximum and Satisfactory	Satisfactory Response Provides a discussion of the results from Second Testing Day and covers most of the results, but is not complete.	Non satisfactory Requirements	Missing
Analysis and Implementation: Second cycle
	Maximum Points 5 pts	Satisfactory Response 4 pts	Non satisfactory Requirements 3 pts	Missing 0 pts	n/a (N/A)
Figure of iteration 2 design	Maximum Points Includes a figure of Iteration 2 that is clear to see.	Satisfactory Response Includes a figure of Iteration 2, but the picture is not clear.	Non satisfactory Requirements	Missing	n/a
Final Comparisons and Recommendations
	Maximum Points 10 pts	Between Maximum and Satisfactory 9 pts	Satisfactory Response 8 pts	Non satisfactory Requirements 7 pts	Missing 0 pts
Compare and contrast your design and the peer design from iteration 1	Maximum Points Discussion comparing the two designs is complete and thorough. References clear distinctions and similarities, particularly in terms of functionality.	Between Maximum and Satisfactory	Satisfactory Response Discusses the two designs, but only briefly and incompletely compares them.	Non satisfactory Requirements	Missing
Describe at least 2 changes you would consider moving forward with reasoning	Maximum Points Describes two changes that should be implemented and provides reason and evidence for doing so.	Between Maximum and Satisfactory	Satisfactory Response Describes two changes that should be implemented, but the reason and evidence for doing so is incomplete.	Non satisfactory Requirements Describes one change, but doesn't present a second change.	Missing
Deductions
	No Deductions 0 pts	Deductions 0 pts	n/a (N/A)	n/a (N/A)	n/a (N/A)
Deductions	No Deductions	Deductions Explain deductions in the comments.	n/a	n/a	n/a

Subjects:

Engineering

Types:

Project

Discuss this rubric