- Username
- Password
forgot?

iRubric: ARCH40511 and ARCH70531 Project rubric

edit print share Copy to my rubrics Bookmark test run assess... delete Do more...
ARCH40511 and ARCH70531 Project EG10116 - Final Deliverable Rubric Code: B2XB59A Ready to use Public Rubric Subject: (General) Type: Project Grade Levels: Undergraduate, Graduate

Memo Descriptions
	Maximum Points 5 pts	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum 4 pts	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum 3 pts	Minimum Requirements 2 pts	Missing 0 pts
Writing Quality	Maximum Points Cohesive memo with clear grammar and formatting.	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum	Minimum Requirements Memo has several grammar and formatting errors.	Missing
Project Introduction	Maximum Points Provide clear, concise and complete introduction to project and description of selected building.	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum	Minimum Requirements Provide unclear and incomplete introduction to project and description of selected building.	Missing
Memo
	Maximum Points 10 pts	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum 8 pts	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum 6 pts	Minimum Requirements 4 pts	Missing 0 pts
Description of Structural System	Maximum Points Provided clear and complete description of structural system.	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum	Minimum Requirements Provided unclear and incomplete description of structural system.	Missing
Rational for Structural System	Maximum Points Provided logical reason(s) for selection of structural system.	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum	Minimum Requirements Provided incorrect or unimportant reason(s) for selection of structural system.	Missing
Occupancy and Live Loads	Maximum Points Provided complete list of occupancy types and required live loads based on ASCE-7.	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum	Minimum Requirements Provided incomplete list of occupancy types and incorrect live loads based on ASCE-7.	Missing
Calculation Set
	Maximum Points 10 pts	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum 8 pts	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum 6 pts	Minimum Requirements 4 pts	Missing 0 pts
Table of Member Sizes	Maximum Points Provided clear summary table of member sizes that includes all members.	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum	Minimum Requirements Provided unclear table of member sizes that did not include all members.	Missing
Documentation of Charts	Maximum Points Provided all charts and sources of information used to determine member sizes.	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum	Minimum Requirements Did not provide all charts and sources of information used to determine member sizes.	Missing
Use of Charts	Maximum Points Charts and other documentation provided with clear annotations and markings to demonstrate the use of the charts.	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum	Minimum Requirements Charts and other documentation did not contain sufficient annotations and markings to demonstrate the use of the charts.	Missing
Drawings
	Maximum Points 30 pts	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum 27 pts	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum 24 pts	Minimum Requirements 21 pts	Missing 0 pts
Logical and Redundant Design	Maximum Points Logical and redundant structural layout for one typical floor. All structural beams/girders supported by walls/columns with clear load paths.	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum	Minimum Requirements Structural layout lacks redundancy. Several structural beams/girders are not clearly supported by walls/columns and load paths are not clear.	Missing
Drawings
	Maximum Points 10 pts	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum 9 pts	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum 8 pts	Minimum Requirements 7 pts	Missing 0 pts
Walls, Columns and LFRS	Maximum Points All bearing walls and columns are clearly identified. LFRS is included in design according to project document guidelines.	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum	Minimum Requirements Bearing walls and columns are not all clearly identified. LFRS is not clearly included in design according to project document guidelines.	Missing
Drawings
	Maximum Points 20 pts	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum 18 pts	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum 16 pts	Minimum Requirements 14 pts	Missing 0 pts
Labels and Dimensions	Maximum Points Included labels for all member size/spacing and overall building dimensions, including beam material, structural decking and/or concrete slab.	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum	Minimum Requirements Several members were not clearly labeled and several dimensions were missing.	Missing
Presentation Quality	Maximum Points Included all needed title block information within professional, complete, organized, and neat drawing.	Closer to Maximum Than Minimum	Closer to Minimum Than Maximum	Minimum Requirements Drawing lacked professionalism in terms of presentation quality.	Missing Note: Point deduction for late submissions included within this category.

Subjects:

Types:

Project

Discuss this rubric